Momentum has long been one of the most celebrated factors in finance. Buy what’s going up, short what’s going down—it sounds simple, almost too good to be true. And at times, it is. Momentum crashes are infamous: sudden reversals that shred portfolios and leave backtests looking like fairy tales. To invest with momentum responsibly, we need to examine when it misbehaves, why, and what can be done to contain the damage.
1) Momentum crashes are real
The classic example: early 2009. Value rebounded, momentum got crushed. Sharp factor reversals tend to happen around turning points in macro regimes, leaving momentum portfolios exposed.
What to do
- Pair momentum with value or quality to soften the blow.
- Cut exposure when realized volatility and correlations spike together.
- Run scenario tests for regime shifts (e.g., sudden easing after a crisis).
2) Crowding makes reversals worse
As more capital chases momentum, the unwind risk grows. When everyone runs for the door, liquidity vanishes and slippage explodes.
What to do
- Track factor crowding metrics (short interest, ETF flows, prime broker data).
- Size positions with liquidity-adjusted risk budgets.
- Favor mid‑liquidity names over crowded mega-caps when possible.
3) Volatility regimes flip the script
Momentum thrives in trending, low‑volatility markets. In whipsaw conditions, it bleeds. Recognizing volatility regimes is essential for deciding when momentum deserves capital.
What to do
- Blend fast and slow volatility filters before allocating to momentum.
- Use trailing stop‑losses or drawdown caps to prevent freefall.
- Be prepared to rotate into other factors during chop.
4) Execution drag is underestimated
High turnover means high costs. Backtests often ignore slippage, borrow fees, and market impact—reality doesn’t.
What to do
- Use execution simulators when backtesting momentum portfolios.
- Reduce trading frequency—weekly rebalances often rival daily ones net of costs.
- Include borrow costs in long/short momentum strategies.
A resilient approach to momentum
- Combine with value/quality for balance.
- Apply volatility filters and regime awareness.
- Budget for liquidity and trading costs upfront.
- Stress‑test across crises and sudden reversals.
Common pitfalls
- Assuming momentum is universally reliable—it isn’t.
- Ignoring execution drag in live trading.
- Overexposing to crowded trades.
Key takeaways
- Momentum is powerful but fragile—its edge depends heavily on market context.
- Risk controls, diversification, and execution discipline keep it investable.
- Expect misbehavior; design systems that survive it.
Bottom line: Momentum is like fire—it can warm your portfolio or burn it down. The key is respecting its danger while harnessing its power.
Have thoughts or counterpoints? Leave a comment or pitch a rebuttal—we publish smart takes, even when they disagree.